Skip to content
Saturday, 21 November 2026
Anine News
Breaking
India

MEA Again Calls US Religious Freedom Panel 'Biased' Over SIR Remarks

India's foreign ministry says USCIRF has a political agenda a day after its chair alleged Muslims were being targeted through voter-roll revisions.

N
By News Desk
New Delhi · Published: · Updated:
हिंदी में पढ़ें

MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal on 20 November rejected USCIRF's allegations about the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, calling the US panel biased and not worth taking seriously. It is India's second such rebuttal in ten days.

MEA Again Calls US Religious Freedom Panel 'Biased' Over SIR Remarks
MEA Again Calls US Religious Freedom Panel 'Biased' Over SIR Remarks Photo: Anine News
Share

Quick answer: India's Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) on Friday, 20 November 2026, again rejected the US Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF), calling it a biased organisation with a blatantly political agenda. The comment came a day after USCIRF chair Asif Mahmood alleged that India is "targeting Muslim citizens" through the removal of names from voter rolls. MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said such a body does not need to be taken seriously.

Who spokeMEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal, at the weekly briefing in New Delhi
Date20 November 2026
TriggerUSCIRF chair Asif Mahmood's statement of 19 November on voter-roll revisions
India's positionUSCIRF is biased, politically motivated and should not be taken seriously
Earlier rebuttal10 November 2026

What did the MEA say about USCIRF?

Speaking at the regular media briefing, Jaiswal said India's view of the US panel had not changed. According to reports of the briefing, he described USCIRF as a biased organisation with a blatantly political agenda and said a body with such prejudice does not merit serious attention. Asked whether India would take up the matter with the US government, he again pointed to the ministry's earlier criticism of the commission.

It was the second public rebuttal in about ten days. On 10 November, the MEA had called USCIRF "biased and ill-informed" and said the commission and its members had stayed silent on attacks on places of worship in the United States and on hate crimes and racial abuse faced by the Indian community there.

What did USCIRF allege?

On 19 November, USCIRF chair Asif Mahmood said the Indian government was "targeting Muslim citizens" by removing them from voter rolls, labelling them "foreigners" and, in his words, "now illegally deporting" them. He also referred to remarks by Union Home Minister Amit Shah describing Muslims as "infiltrators" who should be expelled. These are USCIRF's allegations; the Indian government has rejected the body's credibility rather than accepting the claims.

USCIRF is an independent, bipartisan US government advisory body. Its recommendations are not binding. Its 2026 annual report recommended that the US State Department designate India a "country of particular concern", according to a report by Scroll.

What is the SIR at the centre of the dispute?

SIR stands for Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, conducted by the Election Commission of India. It began in Bihar in 2025 and has since been extended in phases to other states and Union Territories; the third phase, covering 19 states and UTs, is under way, according to reports. Critics say the exercise risks deleting genuine voters, while the Election Commission presents it as a clean-up of the rolls. Reports note that the Supreme Court upheld the legality of the exercise in May 2026 while saying that the Election Commission cannot itself decide whether a person is an Indian citizen.

What happens next?

USCIRF has no power to impose measures on India; it can only make recommendations to the US administration and Congress. The MEA has given no sign that it plans to engage with the commission, and its latest remarks suggest it will keep dismissing the panel's statements. On 14 November, Scroll reported, India's ambassador to the US had also told the commission to reflect on its "prejudices" after a USCIRF post about jailed activist Sharjeel Imam.

Frequently asked questions

What is USCIRF?

The US Commission on International Religious Freedom is an independent, bipartisan body set up by the US Congress to monitor religious freedom worldwide and advise the US government.

Who is the MEA spokesperson?

Randhir Jaiswal is the official spokesperson of India's Ministry of External Affairs.

What did the USCIRF chair say about India?

Asif Mahmood said on 19 November that India was targeting Muslim citizens by removing them from voter rolls and calling them foreigners, and referred to remarks by Amit Shah on "infiltrators".

Are USCIRF's recommendations binding on India?

No. USCIRF only advises the US government. It has no authority over India and its findings are not binding.

Is this the first time India has criticised USCIRF?

No. India has repeatedly criticised the commission, including on 10 November 2026, when the MEA called it biased and ill-informed.

What is the SIR?

The Special Intensive Revision is the Election Commission's exercise to verify and update electoral rolls, carried out in phases across states and Union Territories.

Details are based on the MEA briefing of 20 November 2026 as reported by IANS and Scroll; the SIR background is drawn from the same reports.

Share

Related Stories